RA #5

The source that I chose to do my analysis on is taken from the official BYU evolution packet that is available on campus in the library. It is a compilation of statements put out by various first presidencies concerning the topic of evolution and the creation. The article that I will be using is a message from the First Presidency in the Christmas message in 1910. The audience is most likely faithful members of the Church that read the First Presidency messages. However, I do believe that they had the entire world in mind when writing this because it is an official document put out by the Church. The argument in this article is to set straight exactly how the Church feels about the topic of evolution. They state that diversity in opinion is in no way contrary to the Spirit and that our religion is not hostile to real science. Therefore, they are trying to get across the point that we should not be too quick to dismiss someone else’s opinion as long as it is based on real science. They also continue to say that everything that is in harmony with the teachings of Christ will be favorable to them. This article mostly appeals to ethos because generally any faithful member of the Church will believe and follow exactly what the First Presidency says. It also appeals to logos, because they are presenting very rational ideas to the members by saying that whatever is of good report, they accept. I believe that this article is effective for those that actually read it. Obviously the First Presidency cannot come across too blunt or favoring one side or the other so it may be a little vague and open to interpretation. However, it is very clear that they want us to be accepting of real science that increases our faith in God.